Social Determinants of Health: How We Address Disparities in Cancer Care
When talking about cancer, “patient” and “fighter” often become synonyms. We hear about the brave cancer heroes who win their battle with cancer, and mourn those who lose their fight.
In reality, no two cancer “fights” are the same – it is impossible to lump them all in the same class. A patient can be as strong and resilient as they come, yet still experience challenges that are out of their control.
Social determinants of health (SDOH) are among the challenges weighing against cancer patients. They refer to conditions that influence health outcomes, such as income, housing, food, transportation, race, and ethnicity. They’re largely responsible for health disparities and can, therefore, impact cancer patients’ chances of survival. For example, a patient who earns an hourly wage and doesn’t have health insurance will be at a disadvantage compared to a patient with a salary and benefits who can more easily afford copays and treatment costs.
As a nonprofit that provides financial support to families facing cancer, we know these inequalities well. To further explore how SDOH affect the cancer patients we serve and drive our solutions, we spoke with a few members of our Programs team for their frontline perspectives.
Social determinants from a social worker perspective
Devin Traxler, MSW, LSW, is one of our rockstar in-house social workers, known in Family Reach lingo as a Resource Navigator. Devin and her fellow Navigators work directly with patients and healthcare professionals to review applications to our Financial Treatment Program and match families with the best resources for their needs.
Through her conversations with patients and their families, Devin hears firsthand about concerns surrounding multiple social determinants.
“Patients and caregivers always bring up financial stressors that are connected to SDOH, including difficulty paying for housing, food, gas, and parking costs at the hospitals,” she explained. “Ultimately, SDOH create barriers that make it difficult for patients to access treatment, really at any stage of their cancer journey.”
Devin recalled multiple instances where patients described these barriers. For instance, families with flexible employers or help from their community often move to a different city or state to be closer to their treatment center, while others push through the transportation barriers. Our Navigators know that most cancer patients experience an increase in food costs during treatment because of prescribed diets of fresh, healthy foods as well as long days at the hospital that generally only leave time for takeout meals. But for those who live in “food deserts,” there is the extra challenge of even finding high-quality food close to home.
“I’ve spoken to multiple patients who have to delay getting treatment due to challenges like these,” Devin explained. “And I can’t overstate enough how the COVID-19 pandemic has made all of the barriers more intense.”
Elizabeth Herrig, MSW and Director of Programs at Family Reach, shared similar stories about the uneven playing field patients find themselves on the moment they are diagnosed. She highlighted how low-income families have reduced access to specialized or “top-notch” cancer treatment because the best hospitals are too far from home.
“Treatment centers in lower-income communities often lack the robust staffing and resources needed to bridge the gap to many services for families, such as taxi vouchers or support with SNAP benefits applications,” she explained. “On top of that, families living in these communities may also be up against safety issues like housing security, high crime rates, or severe exposure to air pollution.”
How Do Social Determinants of Health Affect Cancer Patients?
Running into barriers despite “doing everything right”
Patients cannot control how their socioeconomic status influences the challenges they face during cancer treatment, though they often feel ashamed, embarrassed, or frustrated by needing to ask for help.
“There’s a lot of fear and sadness when people reach out to us, and they say ‘but I did everything right,’” Devin explained. “I want to tell them ‘yes, you did, and you are!’ but unfortunately, no one can plan for cancer and there are systems in place that create barriers to care even if you do everything right.”
Availability and affordability aren’t the same for everyone – and this is only highlighted by a health crisis like cancer. What’s more, the various factors that fall under the SDOH umbrella are all so connected that it’s rare for patients to experience the effects of just one social determinant.
“The intersectionality between the many social determinants is extremely important to note,” Devin said. “For example, discrimination in housing creates a system where certain groups of people – primarily Black Americans and underrepresented groups – can’t buy homes in desirable areas. As a result, they can’t build equity, access areas with higher-income jobs, or live near high-ranking school systems. Their children enter the world already at a lower level of privilege -and the data shows that pediatric cancer patients from low-income neighborhoods relapsing faster than those from wealthier communities.”
Patients carry the weight of these systemic challenges long before they connect with Family Reach. But when the challenges pile up, our patient support services like our Financial Treatment Program are there to provide immediate relief.
“Our Resource Navigators introduce patients to government programs like SNAP or local food banks, while our financial guidebooks familiarize families with the hidden costs and our financial planners help them map out an appropriate spending plan,” Elizabeth said. “These are all important steps to relieving the burden for families.”
Measuring social determinants for the full picture
In order to deliver a Financial Treatment Program that provides the right support to the right patients at the right time, we’re continually refining our data collection for the best representation of who we serve and how well our services are performing.
Andrea Incudine, MPH and Senior Manager of Programs and Evaluation at Family Reach, leads the team dedicated to collecting quality data. These questions guide their process:
- Who do we serve?
- Is there any bias in our program delivery?
- Do we reach a more diverse population through our hospital partners or through direct inquiry?
- Are we reaching the most vulnerable populations?
- Are we doing so effectively?
- What changes might we make to our programs to best reach families in need?
To ensure we collect data straight from the source, we ask patients or healthcare providers questions in the Financial Treatment Program application that give us a complete picture of each family’s situation. From there, our team conducts a financial needs assessment to understand the unique risk level of each family. To do this, we consider SDOH factors like household income alongside the financial disruption caused by their cancer diagnosis.
“Our financial needs assessment has two main goals: prioritize the most vulnerable families and identify the most effective financial resources to their meet their needs,” Andrea explained.
Currently, the evaluation team is analyzing the results of two impact surveys – one completed by families we’ve served and another by healthcare professionals we’ve worked with. The goal is to better understand how certain patients may be disproportionately affected by the financial burden and if our programs are making an impact.
“The story this data will tell is still unraveling, but the results will allow us to develop a complete demographic dashboard of our Financial Treatment Program,” Andrea said. “We’ll be able to answer telling questions like what services families receive, if there is any service discrepancy based on race or ethnicity, if gaps in patient satisfaction exist, and whether patients and healthcare professionals feel our services are working.”
Along with this data analysis, we listen to patients to best understand their needs and experiences while also connecting with experts in the cancer care community for their valuable perspective. This collaboration is important for intentional, informed, and effective decision-making.
With staff members as talented and passionate as Devin, Elizabeth, Andrea leading the way, we know our Financial Treatment Program is in good hands. And once it reaches patients, our hope is that the support will break down enough barriers to clear the path to healing.
Always walking the fine line between her right and left brain, Stevie brings her creative and strategic thinking to her role as Creative and Brand Manager. Through writing and design, she amplifies Family Reach’s voice and brings attention to the financial barriers that often accompany a cancer diagnosis.
Our first-ever Giving Day closed out the We See You campaign, honored our 25th anniversary, and raised critical funds for cancer patients.
Find out more about our impact on the cancer community over the years and how we use data to improve our services for patients and families.
Find out how Family Reach evolved from a regional family foundation to a national cancer nonprofit organization.